Spectrum Fine Wine Auctions Home

Auction Lot Listing

Currently Searching Auction # 593 | The February 2020 Auction: Part 2
View Auction Schedule and Details
Currently Viewing: France Bid Paddle My Bids

View All

The February 2020 Auction: Part 2

Lot Location

Orange County, California
Hong Kong, JAS Forwarding
Set Default Warehouse Filter

Quick Search

Red Bordeaux
Dry White Bordeaux
Sweet White Bordeaux
Red Burgundy
White Burgundy
Red California
White California
Red Rhône
White Rhône
Red Italy
White Italy
Red Spain
White Spain
All Sparkling Wines
All Rosé Wines
Beer
Spirits

Country & Appellation

Professional Rating

100
99
98
97
96
95
94
93
92
91
90

Bottle Size

Half Bottle
Jennie
Bottle
Bottle
Bottle
Bottle
Liter
Magnum
Double Magnum
Jeroboam
Imperial

Packaging

OWC

Classification

1er Grand Cru Classé (A)
1er Grand Cru Classé (B)
Auslese
Cru Bourgeois
Cru Classé de Graves
Erste Lage
Grosse Lage
Premier Cru
1er Cru Classé
2eme Cru Classé
3eme Cru Classé
4eme Cru Classé
5eme Cru Classé
Grand Cru Classé
Grand Cru
Premier Cru Supérieur

Vintage

Collections

Hand Picked Selections From the Cellar of Joe Montrachet
The Abacus Cellar
The Acajou Cellar
The Aérienne Cellar
The Agua Fria Cellar
The Alchemy Cellar
The Alton Cellar
The Amapola Cellar
The Apennine Cellar
The Araratian Cellar
The Art Nouvelle Cellar
The Artist’s Great Estates Cellar
The Athènes Cellar
The Atlantic Cellar
The August Cellar
The Azalea Cellar
The Bailliage Cellar
The Barukh Habba Cellar
The Beltway Blue Chips Cellar
The Birmanie Cellar
The Bisque Cellar
The Blue Chip Cellar
The Bonhomme Cellar: The Extraordinary Collection of Irv Wnuck
The Boréal Cellar
The Bourges Cellar
The Bourse Cellar
The Bouteiller’s Cellar
The Bräu Cellar
The Brentwood Heights Cellar
The Brochet Cellar
The Brouillard Cellar
The Calabaza Cellar
The Calamondin Cellar
The California Cult Connoisseur’s Cellar
The Camée Cellar
The Cannelle Cellar
The Carotte Cellar
The Cave Audacieuse Cellar
The Cedrus Cellar
The Chanson Cellar
The Chapelle Cellar
The Chou Cellar
The Chronicle Cellar
The Claret Collection: Direct From Bordeaux
The Colline Cellar
The Comète Cellar
The Conejo Cellar
The Conifère Cellar
The Conque Cellar
The Coquelicot Cellar
The Cordon Cellar
The Craie Cellar
The Cultivateur Cellar
The Dickenson Family Cellar
The Dijon Cellar
The Diplomat’s Cellar
The Double Deuce Cellar
The Eaglecrest Cellar
The Échelle Cellar
The Entente Cellar
The Envy Cellar
The Érable Cellar
The Escrimeur Cellar
The Estragon Cellar
The Étalon Cellar
The Farallon Cellar
The Finsteraarhorn Cellar
The Flatiron Cellar
The Florisando Cellar
The Folio Cellar
The Forêt Cellar
The Formosa Cellar
The Foxy Cellar
The Friendship Cellar
The Garçon Cellar
The Geai Cellar
The Glycine Cellar
The Golden Connection Cellar
The Grand Chapeau Cellar
The Grand Prix Cellar
The Great Wilshire Cult Cellar
The Grecque Cellar
The Griffin Cellar
The Half Moon Cellar
The Haro Cellar
The Hibiscus Cellar
The Hobereaux Cellar
The Homard Cellar
The Iris Cellar
The Irlandais Cellar
The Irvine Ranch Cellar
The Islay Cellar
The Jésuite Cellar
The Kiwi Cellar
The La Palma Cellar
The Laguna Cellar
The Madrid Cellar
The Maltais Cellar
The Maquereau Cellar
The Marteau Cellar: An Extraordinary Collection of Rare Beers and Spirits
The Matador Cellar
The Mesa Cellar
The Métropole Cellar
The Midwest Gentleman’s Century Cellar
The Mission Cellar
The Mistral Cellar
The Moneta Cellar
The Montagne Cellar
The Monte Vista Cellar
The Moonlight Cellar
The Moquette Cellar
The Newsletter Cellar: Legacy Selections from a Renowned Collector
The Normande Cellar
The Orbite Cellar
The Oregon Coast Cellar
The Oroblanco Cellar
The Paganica Cellar
The Papavero Cellar
The Papillon Cellar
The Par Avion Cellar
The Peralejo Cellar
The Piment Cellar
The Piquant Cellar
The Plantagenet Cellar
The Pomme de Terre Cellar
The Pousse Cellar
The Presidio Cellar
The Provençal Cellar
The Receleur Cellar
The Récif Cellar
The Red River Cellar
The Relais Collection
The Roccamonfina Cellar
The Romarin Cellar
The Rose Cellar
The Rouge Cellar
The Royaume Cellar
The Saarbrücken Cellar
The San Gabriel Cellar
The Sans Lequel Pas Cellar
The Santa Ynez Cellar
The Sarrasin Cellar
The Savoir Vivre Cellar
The Sea Cliff Cellar
The Seltenheit Cellar
The Silver Cellar
The Solano Cellar
The Sourire Cellar
The Sunset Boulevard Cellar
The Tanière Cellar
The Thoroughbred Cellar
The Trevian Cellar
The Twisted Pine Cellar
The Valentino Collection: Selections From a Legendary Cellar
The Venatio Regia Cellar
The Vent de L’Ouest Cellar
The Vétérinaire Cellar
The Vieux Quartier Cellar
The Wine Pioneer’s Cellar
The Wisteria Cellar
The Worldrider Cellar
The Zauberberg Cellar
Data pager
Data pager
First PagePrevious Page
Next PageLast Page
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
 2116 items in 43 pages
 LotDescriptionWatch
Data pager
Data pager
First PagePrevious Page
Next PageLast Page
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
 2116 items in 43 pages
Domaine Leroy Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts 2001 201 Domaine Leroy Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts 2001
Session Closed.

Vosne Romanee.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L
Review score 94 AM

The Atlantic Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $1,700

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Domaine Leroy Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts 2001 202 Domaine Leroy Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts 2001
Session Closed.

Vosne Romanee.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L
Review score 94 AM

The Atlantic Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $1,700

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Domaine Leroy Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts 2001 203 Domaine Leroy Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts 2001
Session Closed.

Vosne Romanee.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L
Review score 94 AM

The Atlantic Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $1,700

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Domaine Leroy Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts 2001 204 Domaine Leroy Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts 2001
Session Closed.

Vosne Romanee.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L
Review score 94 AM

The Atlantic Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $1,700

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Bruno Clair Vosne-Romanée Les Champs Perdrix 2009 205 Bruno Clair Vosne-Romanée Les Champs Perdrix 2009
Session Closed.

Vosne Romanee.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L

The Sourire Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $75

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Jean-Marie Fourrier Vosne-Romanée Les Chaumes Vieilles Vignes 2013 206 Jean-Marie Fourrier Vosne-Romanée Les Chaumes Vieilles Vignes 2013
Session Closed.

Vosne Romanee.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L
Review score 91+ JG

The Atlantic Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $90

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Jean Grivot Clos de Vougeot 2001 207 Jean Grivot Clos de Vougeot 2001
Session Closed.

Vougeot.
Consists of 2 Bottles, 0.75L
Review score 92 AM

The Atlantic Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $325

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Jean Grivot Clos de Vougeot 2001 208 Jean Grivot Clos de Vougeot 2001
Session Closed.

Vougeot.
Consists of 2 Bottles, 0.75L
Review score 92 AM

The Atlantic Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $325

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Jean-Marie Fourrier Clos de Vougeot Vieilles Vignes 2011 209 Jean-Marie Fourrier Clos de Vougeot Vieilles Vignes 2011
Session Closed.

Vougeot.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L
Review score 94+ JG

The Atlantic Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $200

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Jean-Marie Fourrier Clos de Vougeot Vieilles Vignes 2012 210 Jean-Marie Fourrier Clos de Vougeot Vieilles Vignes 2012
Session Closed.

Vougeot.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L
Review score 92-94 AG

The Atlantic Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $300

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Pol Roger Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill Brut 1988 211 Pol Roger Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill Brut 1988
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 1 Jeroboam, 3L
Review score 97 RJ

The Grand Prix Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $1,800

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Bertrand Senecourt Beau Joie Brut Rosé NV 212 Bertrand Senecourt Beau Joie Brut Rosé NV
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 6 Bottles, 0.75L

The Wine Pioneer’s Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $475

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Bertrand-Senecourt Beau Joie Special Cuvée Sugar King Rosé Demi-Sec NV 213 Bertrand-Senecourt Beau Joie Special Cuvée Sugar King Rosé Demi-Sec NV
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 6 Bottles, 0.75L

The Normande Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $160

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Bertrand-Senecourt Beau Joie Special Cuvée Sugar King Rosé Demi-Sec NV 214 Bertrand-Senecourt Beau Joie Special Cuvée Sugar King Rosé Demi-Sec NV
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 6 Bottles, 0.75L

The Normande Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $160

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Canard-Duchêne Bicentanaire Brut NV 215 Canard-Duchêne Bicentanaire Brut NV
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 3 Bottles, 0.75L

The Grand Prix Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $160

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



G.H. Mumm Grand Cordon Brut NV 216 G.H. Mumm Grand Cordon Brut NV
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 6 Bottles, 0.75L
Review score 91 WS

The Wine Pioneer’s Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $200

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



G.H. Mumm Grand Cordon Brut NV 217 G.H. Mumm Grand Cordon Brut NV
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 6 Bottles, 0.75L
Review score 91 WS

The Normande Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $160

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



G.H. Mumm Grand Cordon Brut NV 218 G.H. Mumm Grand Cordon Brut NV
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 6 Bottles, 0.75L
Review score 91 WS

The Normande Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $160

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Louis Roederer Cristal Rosé Brut 1988 219 Louis Roederer Cristal Rosé Brut 1988
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L
Review score 98 RJ

The Araratian Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $750

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Moët & Chandon Brut Imperial NV 220 Moët & Chandon Brut Imperial NV
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 6 Bottles, 0.75L OWC.
Review score 92 WS

The Grand Prix Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $250

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Perrier-Jouët Fleur de Champagne Belle Epoque Brut Gift Set 2012 221 Perrier-Jouët Fleur de Champagne Belle Epoque Brut Gift Set 2012
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Perrier-Jouët Fleur de Champagne Belle Epoque Brut 2012
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L

Perrier-Jouët Fleur de Champagne Belle Epoque Champagne Flutes
Consists of 2 Glasses

Review score 95 WE

The Comète Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $150

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Perrier-Jouët Fleur de Champagne Cuvée Belle Epoque Brut 2004 222 Perrier-Jouët Fleur de Champagne Cuvée Belle Epoque Brut 2004
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 1 Magnum, 1.5L OWC.
Review score 94 JS

The Wine Pioneer’s Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $400

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Perrier-Jouët Fleur de Champagne Cuvée Belle Epoque Brut Luminous 2011 223 Perrier-Jouët Fleur de Champagne Cuvée Belle Epoque Brut Luminous 2011
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 6 Bottles, 0.75L
Review score 92 JS

The Wine Pioneer’s Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $1,000

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Perrier-Jouët Fleur de Champagne Cuvée Belle Epoque Brut Luminous 2011 224 Perrier-Jouët Fleur de Champagne Cuvée Belle Epoque Brut Luminous 2011
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 6 Bottles, 0.75L
Review score 92 JS

The Wine Pioneer’s Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $800

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Perrier-Jouët Fleur de Champagne Cuvée Belle Epoque Brut Luminous 2011 225 Perrier-Jouët Fleur de Champagne Cuvée Belle Epoque Brut Luminous 2011
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 6 Bottles, 0.75L
Review score 92 JS

The Wine Pioneer’s Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $800

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Perrier-Jouët Fleur de Champagne Cuvée Belle Epoque Brut Luminous 2011 226 Perrier-Jouët Fleur de Champagne Cuvée Belle Epoque Brut Luminous 2011
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 6 Bottles, 0.75L
Review score 92 JS

The Wine Pioneer’s Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $800

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Perrier-Jouët Fleur de Champagne Cuvée Belle Epoque Rosé 2006 227 Perrier-Jouët Fleur de Champagne Cuvée Belle Epoque Rosé 2006
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 6 Bottles, 0.75L
Review score 94 WE

The Wine Pioneer’s Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $1,000

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Perrier-Jouët Fleur de Champagne Cuvée Belle Epoque Rosé 2006 228 Perrier-Jouët Fleur de Champagne Cuvée Belle Epoque Rosé 2006
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 6 Bottles, 0.75L
Review score 94 WE

The Wine Pioneer’s Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $1,000

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Taittinger Les Folies de la Marquetterie Brut NV 229 Taittinger Les Folies de la Marquetterie Brut NV
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 2 Bottles, 0.75L
Review score 94 WE

The Atlantic Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $250

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Veuve Clicquot Brut Rosé NV 230 Veuve Clicquot Brut Rosé NV
Session Closed.

Champagne.
Consists of 12 Bottles, 0.75L
Review score 91 WS

The Normande Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $550

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Château de Montifaud Cognac Fine Petite Champagne X.O. NV 231 Château de Montifaud Cognac Fine Petite Champagne X.O. NV
Session Closed.

Fine Petite Champagne.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L

The Atlantic Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $100

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Rémy Martin Grande Champagne Cognac Louis XIII (2010s Release) NV 232 Rémy Martin Grande Champagne Cognac Louis XIII (2010s Release) NV
Session Closed.

Grand Champagne.
Consists of 1 Magnum, 1.75L

The Wine Pioneer’s Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $7,500

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Lheraud Cognac Petite Champagne Cuvée 10 NV 233 Lheraud Cognac Petite Champagne Cuvée 10 NV
Session Closed.

Petite Champagne.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L

The Atlantic Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $110

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Lheraud Cognac Petite Champagne V.S NV 234 Lheraud Cognac Petite Champagne V.S NV
Session Closed.

Petite Champagne.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L

The Atlantic Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $110

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Dr. Parce Domaine du Mas Blanc Banyuls 1986 235 Dr. Parce Domaine du Mas Blanc Banyuls 1986
Session Closed.

Banyuls.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L

The Basset Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $45

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Dr. Parce Domaine du Mas Blanc Banyuls 1988 236 Dr. Parce Domaine du Mas Blanc Banyuls 1988
Session Closed.

Banyuls.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L

The Basset Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $45

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Dr. Parce Domaine du Mas Blanc Banyuls Cuvée de la St. Martin 1978 237 Dr. Parce Domaine du Mas Blanc Banyuls Cuvée de la St. Martin 1978
Session Closed.

Banyuls.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L

The Basset Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $50

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Dr. Parce Domaine du Mas Blanc Banyuls Cuvée La Coume 1989 238 Dr. Parce Domaine du Mas Blanc Banyuls Cuvée La Coume 1989
Session Closed.

Banyuls.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L

The Basset Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $45

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Domaine Sainte-Eugénie La Reserve 2011 239 Domaine Sainte-Eugénie La Reserve 2011
Session Closed.

Corbieres.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L

The Santa Ynez Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $35

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Château du Grand Caumont Corbières Tentation 1995 240 Château du Grand Caumont Corbières Tentation 1995
Session Closed.

Corbières.
Consists of 8 Bottles, 0.75L
Review score . WS

The Santa Ynez Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $100

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Puech Chaud Coteaux du Languedoc 2004 241 Puech Chaud Coteaux du Languedoc 2004
Session Closed.

Coteaux du Languedoc.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L

The Sourire Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $12

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



La Liquière Vieilles Vignes 2014 242 La Liquière Vieilles Vignes 2014
Session Closed.

Faugeres.
Consists of 2 Bottles, 0.75L

The Vieux Quartier Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $18

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Domaine Cabirau Serge & Nicolas Maury Sec 2014 243 Domaine Cabirau Serge & Nicolas Maury Sec 2014
Session Closed.

Maury.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L
Review score 93 WSM

The Irlandais Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $30

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Domaine de la Chanteleuserie Bourgueil Vielles Vignes 2005 244 Domaine de la Chanteleuserie Bourgueil Vielles Vignes 2005
Session Closed.

Bourgueil.
Consists of 2 Bottles, 0.75L

The Trevian Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $55

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Charles Joguet Chinon Clos de la Dioterie 2002 245 Charles Joguet Chinon Clos de la Dioterie 2002
Session Closed.

Chinon.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L

The Trevian Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $30

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Charles Joguet Chinon Clos de la Dioterie 2003 246 Charles Joguet Chinon Clos de la Dioterie 2003
Session Closed.

Chinon.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L
Review score 94 JG

The Trevian Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $30

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Soucherie Coteaux du Layon Beaulieu Cuvée de la Tour 1995 247 Soucherie Coteaux du Layon Beaulieu Cuvée de la Tour 1995
Session Closed.

Coteaux du Layon.
Consists of 1 Jennie, 0.5L

The Trevian Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $25

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Philippe Raimbault Sancerre Apud Sariacum 2008 248 Philippe Raimbault Sancerre Apud Sariacum 2008
Session Closed.

Sancerre.
Consists of 2 Bottles, 0.75L

The Santa Ynez Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $25

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Château d 249 Château d'Épiré Savennières (Unfiltered) 2002
Session Closed.

Savennières.
Consists of 1 Bottle, 0.75L

The Trevian Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $25

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Châteauneuf-du-Pape Vieux Télégraphe La Crau 2004 250 Châteauneuf-du-Pape Vieux Télégraphe La Crau 2004
Session Closed.

Chateauneuf du Pape.
Consists of 2 Bottles, 0.75L
Review score 94 WS

The Trevian Cellar

Lot Location: Orange County

Estimate: $70

View Additional Information About This Lot


 
Login to bid



Indicates you are the winner of a lot - Indicates you are the winner of a lot.
Indicates you are the highest bidder of the lot - Indicates you are the highest bidder for a specific lot.
Indicates you are have been outbid on this lot - Indicates you have been outbid on a specific lot.
*Price includes BP if auction is closed
^Reserve not met