It was a pretty interesting day back at the Ritz restaurant in the early 80s tasting the first commercial release from nursery man Gil Nickel. The wine, Far Niente, opened as one of the most expensive Chardonnays in California (at that time around $30), with a complex label that required eleven print run-throughs to complete. No one knew at the time how this bold opening salvo would play out. But, more than three decades later, Far Niente is alive and well.
Gil Nickel was never one to sit still. He founded Dolce, his attempt at a d’Yquem look-alike from Napa, in 1989, a decade after the launch of Far Niente. Still not finished, the ambitious Nickel rolled out the first of his newest venture, Nickel & Nickel, in 2000 and was around long enough to open the showcase winery of the era in 2003. The whole idea of Nickel & Nickel, as opposed to the blended, single brand concept of Far Niente, was to focus on single-vineyard bottlings from the Napa Valley, primarily Cabernet Sauvignon.
Over the years Nickel & Nickel has proven to be one of the finest ‘bargain’ ultra-premium Cabernets in the Napa Valley. While the actual Far Niente label goes ‘direct to the consumer’ for their $250 Oakville Cabernet, these wines hit the shelf at less than half that price…for single vineyard offerings from the Far Niente team.
Huh? (Scratching head)
We still don’t get it…but shhhh, don’t tell them that.
The 2021 Nickel & Nickel wines, whether due to the greatness of the vintage, Russian paratroopers, harmonic convergence or what have you, are easily the finest range we’ve tasted from this talented team. Winemaker Joe Harden, after several vintages under his belt (after previously guiding the To Kalon program at Mondavi for a half-dozen years) perhaps has finally got ‘the feel’ for all these vineyard specific sites and can now really guide these wines towards greatness.
Because the 2021’s, folks, are great. As Joe notes, “The growing season kicked off under drought conditions with little winter rain, causing an early budbreak and bloom in the spring, followed by a warm but mild summer. The favorable growing season allowed our vines to ripen slowly and evenly, yielding small but intensely flavored grapes. The closer we got to harvest, it was evident that 2021 would be one for the ages.”
‘One for the ages’ indeed! As we tasted through the range (including their terrific Post & Beam and Bella Union Cabs) we were awestruck at the quality here, which wasn’t bad before, mind you. Chuck these in a blind Cabernet tasting with ‘fahncier’ wines at twice the price and see how they do…
For today’s missive we’re featuring two of our faves from the range (though we bought all of the wines we tasted). Both of these wines share a heftiness (no shrinking violets here!) allied with fine tannins and a perfect equilibrium that we encountered all the way down the line, allowing their vineyard nuances to shine…and that’s the whole point, right?
The Nickel & Nickel Cabernet Sauvignon Fog Break Atlas Peak 2021 ($109.98), a newer offering for them, comes from a 20-acre block, certified organic, just past the famed Stagecoach Vineyard. This rugged terroir at 1400ft elevation is composed of decomposed rocky outcrops, giving the wine kind of a Howell Mountain mojo.
From James Suckling, “97 Points! Outstanding balance and complexity from the beginning that showcases concentrated black fruits and purple flowers with plenty of spices and subtle yet harmonious toast and cedar aromas. Intense graphite and stony minerality, too. Full- to medium-bodied on the mid-palate with delightful acidity that gives this wonderful crunchiness. Fine-grained juicy tannins. Precisely focused wine that is colorful and sound. Beautiful length, too. Already so drinkable now but will age gracefully, especially for Atlas Peak. Try after 2027.”
The second-highest score he’s ever given a wine from Atlas Peak (‘98’ being the highest), he knows its groundbreaking stuff!
The Nickel & Nickel Cabernet Sauvignon State Ranch Yountville 2021 ($109.98) is one of the ‘OG’s’, launched with the initial program if memory serves. Here, just north of the Stag’s Leap District border, the soil is classic valley floor Bale Clay loam, giving the wine a plush texture yet haunting balance from this cooler southside terroir. Some of you may know this vineyard as ‘State Lane’ produced under the Kapcsandy label.
From Suckling, “97 Points! Bright aromas of black currants and lavender with intense pencil shavings and green tobacco leaves followed by roasted coffee beans and cedar. A full-bodied wine that is broad on the mid-palate with firm yet fine-grained tannins and bright acidity. Great depth and length here. Wonderful tension and density as well as harmony. Try after 2028.”
The perfect gifts! Great label, great name, great scores, great vintage...