History is important in Burgundy with each village, indeed each vineyard establishing its reputation based on its performance over the centuries. Lineage can also play an important part in the process. The vineyard is important, and so is the vintage. But you can get a top vineyard in a great vintage that doesn’t quite perform to expectations. It still takes the right vigneron to see it through. That’s the mystery of Burgundy.
There are certain names in Burgundy that are iconic and have the kind of rock star reputations that eliminate any fear of mediocrity. Names like Roumier, Romanee Conti, and Dujac are examples of hallowed producers whose fame has expanded to the point where they can command almost unbelievable prices. Of similar reputations, indeed definitely in that ‘icon’ territory, are Henri Jayer and Emmanuel Rouget. Any connection to such names should be taken with the utmost seriousness.
Maxime Cheurlin is a name you may not be familiar with yet. But he is one of the wunderkinds of the next generation and in charge of one of Vosne Romanée's greatest estates, Domaine Georges Noellat. How’s this for Burgundy lineage? Georges Noellat was Maxime's grandfather. Since Georges’ passing in the late 90's, Maxime’s grandmother was in charge of the domaine, selling the vast majority of the production to Louis Jadot and Joseph Drouhin. The recent expiration of a 20-year contract between the domaine and those titans of the Burgundy trade meant that Maxime, even before he could order a beer in the states (he was 20), was handed some of the finest Pinot Noir vineyards in the world. Problem? Not really.
Winemaking has been in Maxime's blood since birth. Maxime is a nephew of the Jayer family and a cousin of Guillaume Rouget, son of Emmanuel Rouget, who trained with the legendary Henri Jayer for many years before opening his own eponymous domaine (whose wines pretty much vaporize in the marketplace every year). Maxime and Guillaume Rouget are constant companions, always tasting, learning, and growing into their crafts. In fact, Maxime did a good bit of the winemaking at the heralded Rouget estate in 2009 and with another Burgundy heavyweight, Gros Frère et Sœur in Vosne Romanée, in 2008.
Maxime's style of winemaking is very close to Emmanuel Rouget’s, richly appointed, sleek, silky wines with an amazing clarity and focus, with, like many of his peers in Vosne, a healthy dollop of new oak (but never enough to get in the way). The winemaking regimen is familiar. Hand-harvesting, cool maceration and fermentation via native yeasts, gentle winemaking and 14-20 months in barrel prior to being bottled unfiltered and unfined with low levels of sulfur. The word ‘transparency’ gets bandied about in the world of high-end Burgundy. But we have to say that is a perfect descriptor for Maxime’s wines. They convey the respective terroir of their origins consistently. Within the Burgundy cognoscenti, Maxime is a rock star these days and his prices have been on an upward trajectory for some time.
His stuff also isn’t in wide market distribution as you might imagine. So when we saw a parcel of Domaine Georges Noellat wines a little while ago from the outstanding 2016 vintage at reasonable fares, we were all over it. As we tasted through them for this piece (somebody has to do it), it was remarkable how each of these perfectly reflected the village that they came from. This is not only a lovely display of sleek, sexy Burgundy at its most beguiling but also a virtual lesson in the classic characteristics that make each of these villages unique. Delicious and, dare we say, even educational. We have bits and pieces of the following (click on the individual wine name to purchase!):
The Georges Noellat Beaune 1er Cru Les Tuvilains 2016 isn’t a Beaune vineyard we’ve run across previously. But it lies on the lower part of the hill surrounded by the sources of familiar, favorite Jadot bottlings Chouacheux, Avaux, and Clos des Ursules. This is apparently the first bottling from this site with yields reduced by 75% due to frost. It’s from a .66 ha parcel planted in 1983 consisting of brown clay on limestone. The nose shows pure blackberry and black cherry with hints of spice and a little clove. In the mouth, the fruit leans a little redder with deceptive weight and thrust, and intermittent flecks of spice, sweet earth and mineral with pleasing grip to the finish. This is a Beaune with both elegance and power and still youthful at age 6.
The Georges Noellat Nuits-Saint-Georges 2016 comes from 50-year-old vines. It is a blend of two lieu dits, Au Bas de Combe (just below Aux Boudots) and Longecourt (just below Les Saint Georges). A jewel-like deep ruby color, the nose centers on dark red fruits with both violets and stones as accents. Sweet dark red fruit with surprising power for Pinot Noir, plenty of minerality and savory accents, and that very ‘Nuits’ lick of dusty iron at the end. Again, a lovely, long, and typically authoritative rendition of the village with plenty of life.
It should be no surprise that our albeit slight favorite was the Georges Noellat Vosne Romanee 2016, comprised of four separate parcels with vines averaging 50 years-of-age. Maybe a slightly darker hue than the Nuit, it has that inviting nose of dark cherries, Asian spices, and anise that are the calling card of this village. Broad, sweet, and very spicy and layered in the mouth, superb balance and definition, with plenty of spice rack through the finish, this is a prototypical and very engaging example of this special village.
The Georges Noellat Gevrey Chambertin Vieilles Vignes 2016 (bottled under the Maxime Cheurlin label) identifies itself immediately when you stick your nose in the glass. The aromas are a mélange of dark fruits with a lot of spice, smoke and that definitive Gevrey gravel-like minerality in the mix. Again, there’s deceptive power and grip with dark red and black fruit, fine tannins, some caramel notes alongside the insistent Gevrey minerality. Lots of sweet, focused fruit on the palate, the terroir shines through at every turn. This is definitive Gevrey.
There are also small bits of these rare Premier Crus:
Georges Noellat Nuits Saint Georges 1er Cru Aux Boudots 2016 is from a 1.2 ha plot of 90-year-old vines in one of the top sites in Nuits-Saint-Georges. It comes from a very steep slope with rocky soils. Completely de-stemmed and fermented with indigenous yeast, the juice sees 18 months in oak, 80% new. From Burghound, “There is good muscle to the intense bigger-bodied flavors that still manage to retain a relatively refined mouthfeel while tightening up on the focused and impressively complex finish that delivers sneaky good length. While this is certainly firm it should drink reasonably well young if that's your preference.”
Georges Noellat Nuits Saint Georges 1er Cru Aux Cras 2016 from Wine Advocate (Dec, 2017), “The 2016 Nuits Saint Georges 1er Cru Aux Cras was more backward on the nose compared to the domaine’s other 2016s, partly because it underwent a late malolactic, according to Maxime Chuerlin. The palate is medium-bodied with candied red berry fruit on the entry mixed with cassis and ink. I appreciate the grainy structure here, but it is more backward and sultry than Maxime’s other barrel samples at the moment. That said, it is clearly well defined and harmonious on the finish, and it should develop with style once in bottle…”
Georges Noellat Vosne Romanee 1er Cru Les Beaux Monts 2016 comes from a .45 ha parcel of century-old vines in stony limestone soils. One of the top Premier Crus in Vosne, arguably the highest rent district in all of Burgundy. It spent 18 months in barrel, 50% new. Barrel scores of 91-94 from both Burghound (also the little ‘heart’) and Steve Tanzer. Wine Advocate’s William Kelley writes, “The 2016 Vosne-Romanée 1er Cru Les Beaux Monts is showing well from bottle, unwinding in the glass to offer up a youthfully reserved bouquet of blackberries, cherries, plums, grilled game bird, rich soil and smoky new oak. On the palate, the wine is medium to full-bodied, rich and voluptuous, with a succulent core of fruit, vibrant fruit flavors and a fine-grained framing of structuring tannins. It's appreciably more reserved than earlier renditions of this cuvée, perhaps because Maxime Cheurlin now has an air-conditioned cellar and is maturing his wine for two winters in barrel. It will be interesting to follow its evolution over the coming decade….”
Maxime’s wines are already commanding substantially higher prices in the open market than the prices we’re offering today. Do the research, please! As an end-of-year thank you we’re letting you in on the ground floor of one of the hottest names in Burgundy at prices WAY under market.
Come to think of it, kind of what we’ve always done…Happy Hunting…