Here’s a scoop for you guys. Piaggia isn’t just the finest producer in Tuscany’s tiny appellation of Carmignano, they’re actually one of the greatest wineries in Italy. Hands down, no contest, Do NOT fight me on this one.
The long-awaited Piaggia Carmignano Riserva 2021 is just a mind-bendingly great bottle of wine. How great? It makes the short list of ‘desert island’ Sangiovese wines I’d require for sustenance…at any price.
It’s a testament to the work that the Vannucci family continues to do in their vineyards in Carmignano, just north of Florence. As we’ve talked about in the past, Carmignano is truly a unique winegrowing area in Tuscany. Though there was a tradition of growing Cabernet Sauvignon in this zone since the 1800’s, it was vine cuttings of Cabernet from Château Lafite Rothschild in Bordeaux that found their way into Carmignano’s vineyards and kick-started quality, imparting a bolder, classier character to the Sangiovese from here and, by 1975, Carmignano was the first DOC in Tuscany to be awarded official sanctioning for the use of Cabernet in the blend.
The Piaggia farm is situated in the hilly commune of Poggio a Caiano, in the province of Prato, about eight miles west of Florence. The winery was set up by Mauro Vannucci, who purchased the land in the mid-70’s; he was convinced that the excellent exposure to the sun and the permeable, dry and clayey soil would produce a great Carmignano wine.
He produced the first Piaggia Carmignano Riserva DOCG in 1991 and since then his passion for wine has steadily grown. He has involved his daughter Silvia in this project and she is now the current owner of the winery. Together they produce some of the most compelling Sangiovese in Italy…at an extremely reasonable price.
Their style is certainly modern, but not due to the oak, which is not apparent in the wine. Instead, it’s the silky quality of the tannin and the vibrancy of the fruit that lends an ear to modernity, the wine is a perfect synthesis of the red-fruited Sangiovese and the more cassis-inflected Cabernet Sauvignon providing a bigger, bolder backbone.
From Vinous’ Eric Guido, “The Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc and Merlot found throughout these 50-year-old vines are said to have been planted from cuttings taken from Château Lafite Rothschild in Bordeaux. All of the plantings throughout the vineyards acquired by Piaggia since have been through massal selection from these same vines. Today, Piaggia oversees 15 hectares of vineyards, ranging from 190 to 250 meters above sea level, to create their portfolio of Crus and blends. The style is one of pure elegance and class, without relying heavily on oak influence…Frankly speaking, Piaggia is the estate that has kept Carmignano on the map; and while there are a number of up-and-coming as well as long-time producers making great wines, Silvia Vannucci has already set the benchmark quite high.”
This wine certainly gets my vote for best Sangiovese in the store under $50….and whups many a Brunello…at twice the price!
From Eric in his Vinous Media article, “The 2021 Carmignano Riserva Piaggia takes its time in the glass, tempting the imagination with dried violets and flowery underbrush that evolve into peppery wild berries, autumnal spices and a dusting of cocoa. Elegant and velvety in feel, this sweeps across the palate, gaining contrast through a core of mineral-inflected yet pleasantly ripe red and black fruits. Tantalizing acidity guides the experience. The 2021 finishes with dramatic length and concentration, leaving a bitter blackberry resonance to mingle with edgy tannins, while a hint of blood orange forces the mouth to water for more. The contrasting nature and sheer depth of the 2021 leave me in awe. Bury this deep in the cellar. 97 points!”
That is a HUGE number from Vinous, higher than many other Tuscan wines at substantially higher prices. Lord, if that doesn’t ring your bells, I don’t know what will…only 14 cases available…
Piaggia Carmignano Riserva 2021
97 Points! The 2021 Carmignano Riserva Piaggia takes its time in the glass, tempting the imagination with dried violets and flowery underbrush that evolve into peppery wild berries, autumnal spices and a dusting of cocoa. Elegant and velvety in feel, this sweeps across the palate, gaining contrast through a core of mineral-inflected yet pleasantly ripe red and black fruits. Tantalizing acidity guides the experience. The 2021 finishes with dramatic length and concentration, leaving a bitter blackberry resonance to mingle with edgy tannins, while a hint of blood orange forces the mouth to water for more. The contrasting nature and sheer depth of the 2021 leave me in awe. Bury this deep in the cellar.